One of the most compelling aspects of Broadside is its confidence as a piece of theatrical storytelling. Rather than simply recounting the familiar milestones of the American Revolution, the musical chooses an unexpected guide: Phillis Wheatley. It is a fascinating dramatic choice, giving narrative authority to a woman whose voice was so often questioned during her own lifetime. By allowing Wheatley to frame the story, the production quietly reminds us that history is not only shaped by those in power, but also by those whose words endured despite every obstacle. Shonsharae Tull brings grace, intelligence, and quiet strength to the role. Her portrayal grounds the production, providing a thoughtful perspective that ties together the political upheaval with the deeply human stories unfolding around it. Rather than dominating the stage, she elevates it, making Phillis Wheatley an essential presence throughout the evening.
![]() |
| Sonsharae Tull as Phillis Wheatley |
Patrick Brownson delivers a memorable portrayal of Governor Thomas Hutchinson, capturing both the dignity and frustration of a man watching the world shift beneath him. Equally compelling is the nuanced relationship between Margaret and Thomas Gage, whose marriage provides the emotional heart of the production. Their divided loyalties offer a deeply personal perspective on a conflict too often reduced to politics. Meanwhile, the fiery Dr. Joseph Warren and Paul Revere lead the Sons of Liberty with conviction and urgency, balancing idealism with revolutionary zeal.
![]() |
| Patrick Brownson as Governor Thomas Hutchinson |
The production is equally successful in its visual world. The period costumes create a convincing eighteenth-century Boston without ever feeling museum-like, while an elegantly simple set makes effective use of colonial barrels, hand-printed broadsides, and even a beautifully incorporated clavichord to establish both time and place. Rather than relying on spectacle, the production favors carefully chosen period details that enrich the storytelling, allowing the characters to inhabit history while keeping the narrative immediate, authentic, and accessible.
![]() |
| Tanner Kelly as Sam Adams with his pseudonyms |
Perhaps the evening's most delightful sequence is the play-within-a-play, where the production embraces its theatricality with wit and charm. It pairs beautifully with the Daughters of Liberty, whose spinning circle becomes both a place of resistance and sisterhood as they quietly weave their way through the Revolution. It's a clever reminder that history is often moved forward not only by speeches and battles, but by ordinary people finding extraordinary ways to act.
![]() |
| Gunnar Bettis as Paul Revere acting as the Governor |
Like many new musicals, Broadside is not yet a finished work. There are moments where pacing, transitions, and dramatic focus could be sharpened, and a handful of scenes would benefit from further refinement. Yet those are the kinds of challenges that arise from execution rather than conception. The underlying architecture of the piece is remarkably strong, suggesting a work with the potential to grow into something genuinely significant.
![]() |
| Kelly McAllister plays John Adams with passion |
At its heart, Broadside is less about celebrating the past than examining the ideals that emerged from it. Liberty, equality, and freedom are presented not as settled achievements, but as aspirations that every generation is challenged to redefine and defend. By the final curtain, the audience is left contemplating the enduring American experiment, not as a completed story, but as one still being written. If Broadside continues to evolve with the same imagination that inspired its foundation, it has every opportunity to become an important new work of American musical theatre.
![]() |
| The cast on set at Vintage Theatre |
Verdict: Broadside may still have refinements ahead of it, but its imagination, emotional intelligence, and inventive approach to history make it one of the more promising new musicals to emerge in recent years. It's a production with a solid artistic foundation and the potential to grow into a lasting work of musical theatre.
Recommendation: A must-see for lovers of new musicals, American history, and thoughtful theatre. Whether you're drawn by the Revolutionary story, the soaring period-inspired score, or simply the chance to experience an original work finding its voice, Broadside is well worth your time.














